Porsche sold seven distinct cars in 1991, spread across three completely different platforms, and most “spec sheet” pages online only give you one at a time. Here’s the whole lineup in one place, with the numbers that matter and the ones that don’t.
Table of Contents
- The Quick Answer
- Why 1991 Matters in Porsche History
- 911 Carrera 2 and Carrera 4 (964)
- 911 Turbo 3.3 (964)
- 928 S4 and 928 GT
- 944 S2 Coupe and Cabriolet
- Full Comparison Table
- Which One Should You Actually Buy
The Quick Answer

Seven cars, three families:
- 911 Carrera 2 — rear-drive, 3.6L flat-six, 247 hp, the volume seller
- 911 Carrera 4 — same engine, all-wheel drive, the one Porsche launched the 964 with
- 911 Turbo 3.3 — carried-over 930 turbo motor, 320 hp, the fastest-accelerating production car of its year
- 928 S4 — V8 grand tourer, 320 hp, its final model year
- 928 GT — manual-only, 330 hp, the enthusiast’s 928
- 944 S2 Coupe — 3.0L four-cylinder, 208 hp, the last and best of the non-turbo 944s
- 944 S2 Cabriolet — same drivetrain, open top
If you want the short version: the Carrera 2 is the easiest to live with, the Turbo is the one that’s actually appreciating fast, and the 944 S2 is the cheapest real way into an air-cooled-era Porsche.
Why 1991 Matters in Porsche History
1991 sits in the middle of the 964 generation — the 911 that replaced torsion-bar suspension with coil springs, added power steering and ABS as standard, and quietly redesigned 85% of the car’s parts under a body that still looked like a 911. Porsche’s own account of the car’s development frames it as a full reengineering wearing a familiar suit, not a facelift.
It’s also the last stretch before Porsche’s early-90s cost crisis forced changes across the range. The 928 was down to its final model year as an S4 before the GTS took over in 1992. The 944 had one more year left before the 968 replaced it entirely. And the 911 itself would move to the 993 in 1994, built with more automated, less labor-intensive methods than the 964. If you want a Porsche from the tail end of the era when hand-finishing still mattered more than production efficiency, 1991 is close to the last call.
911 Carrera 2 and Carrera 4 (964)
Both cars share the same 3.6-liter air-cooled flat-six: 247 hp at 6,100 rpm, 228 lb-ft at 4,800 rpm, a 5-speed manual standard with a 4-speed Tiptronic automatic as an option. The Carrera 2 sends power to the rear wheels only; the Carrera 4 splits it to all four through a viscous-coupling system that was new for the 964.
The Carrera 2 is the quicker, lighter, more direct car — roughly 5.7 seconds to 62 mph, a 3,031-lb curb weight in coupe form, and the steering feel people actually buy air-cooled 911s for. The Carrera 4 carries extra hardware weight and a slightly duller front end in exchange for real all-weather traction, which mattered enough to Porsche that it launched the 964 as a Carrera 4-only car in 1989 before adding the rear-drive Carrera 2 a year later.
Body styles multiply the decision: Coupe, Cabriolet, and Targa were available on the Carrera 2, with the Cabriolet running about 130 lbs heavier than the coupe. None of that changes the drivetrain — it changes weight distribution, rigidity, and, for better or worse, resale demand. Coupes hold value hardest; Targas are the value play if you don’t mind the smaller enthusiast market for them.

911 Turbo 3.3 (964)
The 964 Turbo didn’t get the new 3.6-liter engine the naturally aspirated cars did. Porsche kept the older 3.3-liter turbocharged flat-six from the outgoing 930, refined it, and bolted it into the new chassis — 320 hp at 5,750 rpm, 332 lb-ft at 4,500 rpm, 0-62 mph in around 5.0 seconds, and a claimed top speed of 168 mph. At launch, that made it the fastest-accelerating production car sold that year.
It’s also the only 1991 911 without a Tiptronic option — manual, rear-drive, no compromise. Base price landed at $97,800 in the U.S., which was serious money against a Carrera 2 starting closer to $61,000. That price gap has only widened with time: the Turbo 3.3 now trades in an entirely different bracket from the naturally aspirated cars, with clean examples routinely clearing six figures and exceptional ones well past it.
This is the one 1991 Porsche most likely to be bought as an investment rather than a driver. That changes what to look for — matching numbers, original paint, and full service history matter more here than on any other car in this lineup.
928 S4 and 928 GT
The 928 was never trying to be a 911. It’s a front-engine, water-cooled V8 grand tourer, built for autobahn cruising rather than back-road agility, and 1991 was the last year of the S4 before the GTS took over the nameplate in 1992.
The S4 runs a 5.0-liter, 32-valve V8 producing 320 hp at 6,000 rpm and 317 lb-ft at 3,000 rpm, available with either a 4-speed automatic or 5-speed manual. The GT is the sharper edition Porsche layered on top: 330 hp at 6,200 rpm from the same displacement, a limited-slip differential, firmer suspension, and manual transmission only — no automatic offered. Ten extra horsepower doesn’t sound like much on paper, but the GT’s chassis changes and manual-only rule make it feel like a genuinely different car to drive, not a trim sticker.
928s remain the most underpriced Porsches of this era relative to what they actually offer — a 300-plus-horsepower V8 grand tourer for a fraction of what a Carrera 2 costs. The GT trades on scarcity: fewer were built, and the manual-only, driver-focused spec has slowly turned it into the 928 collectors actually chase.
944 S2 Coupe and Cabriolet
The 944 S2 is a four-cylinder story, which sounds like a step down until you look at the numbers. Porsche bored the 944’s engine out to 3.0 liters and gave it a 16-valve dual-overhead-cam head, netting 208 hp at 5,800 rpm and 207 lb-ft at 4,100 rpm — at the time, the largest production four-cylinder engine in the world. 0-60 mph runs about 6.9 seconds, with a top speed near 149 mph.
The Cabriolet, added to the U.S. lineup for the 1990 model year and continuing through 1991, uses the identical drivetrain in an open body. It’s heavier and marginally less rigid than the coupe, but it’s also the rarer, more sought-after body style today among S2 buyers who want top-down driving without stepping up to a 911 Cabriolet’s price.

This is also the 944 generation most worth caring about. The S2’s engine and chassis upgrades over the base 944 — bigger brakes, the aero-tuned nose, the stiffer subframe — make it the version enthusiasts actually seek out, rather than settling for a 944 because it’s cheap.
Buyer Notes: What Actually Breaks
Every 1991 Porsche in this lineup is over three decades old, and age-related failure points matter more than horsepower figures when you’re deciding what to buy.
On the air-cooled 911s, the classic trap is the rear main seal — a leak that starts small and, if ignored, can take out a clutch and escalate into a full engine-out repair according to the Porsche Club of America’s own technical guidance. Cars that sat unused for long stretches often weep at first startup simply because the seal needs heat cycles to stay sealed; that’s different from a car that’s actively dumping oil, and a pre-purchase inspection should tell them apart. Suspension bushings and dampers are due around 70,000 miles, and power-steering seals are a known wear item worth budgeting for.
On the 944 S2, the timing belt is the whole ballgame. These are interference engines — if the belt lets go, it bends valves and can damage the head. Belts need replacement roughly every four years or 48,000 miles regardless of how good the car looks otherwise, and the water pump should go out with it since it’s driven off the same belt. A 944 S2 with no documented belt history isn’t a car to buy on faith.
The 928’s V8 is comparatively robust, but it’s a complex, expensive car to service by nature — specialist labor rates apply, and the timing belt job on a 928 is a bigger undertaking than on a 944. Budget accordingly rather than being surprised by it.
Full Comparison Table
| Model | Engine | Horsepower | 0-60 mph | Drivetrain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 911 Carrera 2 | 3.6L flat-six | 247 hp | ~5.7 sec | RWD |
| 911 Carrera 4 | 3.6L flat-six | 247 hp | ~5.8 sec | AWD |
| 911 Turbo 3.3 | 3.3L turbo flat-six | 320 hp | ~5.0 sec | RWD |
| 928 S4 | 5.0L V8 | 320 hp | ~6.0 sec | RWD |
| 928 GT | 5.0L V8 | 330 hp | ~5.7 sec | RWD |
| 944 S2 Coupe | 3.0L inline-4 | 208 hp | ~6.9 sec | RWD |
| 944 S2 Cabriolet | 3.0L inline-4 | 208 hp | ~7.1 sec | RWD |
Which One Should You Actually Buy
If you want a 911 you can drive every weekend without thinking about it, the Carrera 2 Coupe is the answer — it’s the most plentiful, the best supported by specialists, and the closest thing to a “default” 964. Want the same car in snow or wet climates you can’t avoid? The Carrera 4 gives up a little steering feel for genuine four-season usability.
If straight-line performance is the point, the Turbo 3.3 is the only car on this list built around that goal, and its values reflect it — this is the one to buy as an appreciating asset, not a bargain.
If you want V8 grand-touring comfort and don’t care about badge prestige, the 928 S4 remains the most car-per-dollar in this entire lineup, and the GT is worth chasing specifically for its manual gearbox and sharper chassis if you can find one.
And if the goal is simply getting into an air-cooled-era Porsche for the least money while still owning something genuinely quick and well-engineered, the 944 S2 — coupe for the sharper chassis, cabriolet for open-top driving — does that job better than any 911 in this list ever will.
How we reviewed this article
This article was researched against manufacturer records and editorially reviewed before publishing. We accept no payment for coverage. Some guides contain affiliate links; see our affiliate disclosure.


